WebIn particular, I argue that many thick concepts (if not all) conceptually entail evaluative contents. The Semantic View has a number of outspoken critics, but I shall limit discussion to the most recent—Pekka Väyrynen—who believes that objectionable thick concepts present a problem for the Semantic View. Webbeen used to argue against the view that thick terms and concepts are inherently evaluative in meaning. Such views require that sentences or propositions involving thick terms and concepts analytically entail evaluation. The main idea behind arguments from contextual variabil-ity is that one should find it hard to see how that could be so if the
Christine Tappolet, Evaluative vs. Deontic Concepts - PhilPapers
Web13 de abr. de 2012 · These two views might aptly be classified as semantic theories of the relation between thick terms and their evaluative contents. For a defense of a semantic view, see Kyle (2011, Ch. 1). Some people reject semantic theories and instead hold that the evaluative contents are only pragmatically associated with thick terms (e.g. see … Web37 eye”, sensitivity to human practical concerns, to determine or recognise their instances.71 Thus, for instance, Debbie Robert’s (2013) version72 of the thesis that thick concepts are inherently evaluative is formulated as a claim about what makes a concept evaluative in terms of property ascription, where the notion of ‘ascribing an evaluative … notion templates dark academia
Additional Debates about Thick Concepts and Their Significance
WebIn philosophy, a thick concept (sometimes: thick normative concept, or thick evaluative concept) is a kind of concept that both has a significant degree of descriptive content and is evaluatively loaded.Paradigmatic examples are various virtues and vices such as courage, cruelty, truthfulness and kindness.Courage for example, may be given a rough … WebHow Are Thick Terms Evaluative? Brent G. Kyle - 2013 - Philosophers' Imprint 13:1-20. What are Thick Concepts? Matti Eklund - 2011 ... Shapelessness and the thick. Debbie Roberts - 2011 - Ethics 121 (3):489-520. Thinning the Thicket: Thick Concepts, Context, and Evaluative Frameworks. Kenneth Shockley - 2012 - Environmental Ethics 34 (3):227 ... Web25 de abr. de 2013 · What is the difference between judging someone to be good and judging them to be kind? Both judgements are typically positive, but the latter seems to offer more description of the person: we get a more specific sense of what they are like. Very general evaluative concepts (such as good, bad, right and wrong) are referred to as thin … notion templates for coding